New York

Motion to Change Venue Denied Despite Being Unopposed (NY)

In Francoise Mervil v. Eric Johnson and Marcia St. Urbain, Judge Francois A. Rivera denied Defendants’ unopposed motion to transfer venue because the only evidence in support of the Defendants’ motion constructed of inadmissible hearsay. Plaintiff, Francoise Mervil (“Mervil”) commenced a personal injury action against the Defendants in Kings County Supreme Court, alleging Urbain was negligent...Read More

Lack Of Maintenance Records Leads To Denial Of Summary Judgment (NY)

In Smith v Montefiore Medical Center, 2021 NY Slip Op 01872 (1st Dept. 2021), the First Dept. reviewed a denial by the lower court of a defendant’s motion for summary judgment. Plaintiff alleged that he slipped and fell on dirty ice in front of the emergency room at the Montefiore Hospital. The spot of the fall was covered by a canopy. Montefiore moved for summary judgment, noting that two of...Read More

Kings County Suit Dismissed During Jury Selection Due to Mask Protocols (NY)

Just yesterday in Kings County Supreme Court, a plaintiff’s attorney expressed an inability to proceed with jury selection, while masked, due to inability to breathe.  Counsel asked for an adjournment of trial until June.   Not only did the Court deny the request, but dismissed the lawsuit outright due to counsel’s inability to proceed.   The transcript of the argument which lead...Read More

Another Covid-19 Victory for Insurers, This Time in New Jersey (NJ)

In a short, terse opinion, a federal judge in New Jersey ruled this week that owners of Wendy’s, T.G.I. Friday’s, Marriott, and Hilton franchises cannot recover for losses caused by Covid-19-related shutdowns. The decision adds to the growing amount of case law on this issue which has significantly favored insurers over policyholders. In Manhattan Partners, LLC v. American Guarantee &...Read More

COVID-19 Illness is a Reasonable Excuse for Default (NY)

Solomon v. Gun Hill Assoc Trust, No. 24150, 2021 WL 923114 (Bronx Cty. Sup. Ct. Feb. 26, 2021) is a personal injury case, wherein Plaintiff alleged damages after a trip-and-fall in a driveway leading to a parking lot jointly used by several businesses. Defendant Dunkin’ Donuts Franchising, LLC (“Dunkin”) previously moved for summary judgment on the grounds that – by virtue of its franchise...Read More

NYPD Traffic Officer Traffic Owed No Special Duty to Plaintiff Struck by Taxi

On November 1, 2012, an NYPD traffic officer was directing traffic at the intersection of 3rd Avenue and East 10th Street in Manhattan, New York, after the traffic lights were non-operational due to Hurricane Sandy. As the officer was manually directing traffic, a collision occurred at the intersection between a motorcycle driven by the Plaintiff and a taxi. Subsequently, in Mendez v. City of...Read More

Vicious Propensity Rule: Not a Protection for All (NY)

In Hewitt v. Palmer Veterinary Clinic, PC, 35 N.Y.3d 541, 547, 159 N.E.3d 228, 231 (2020), the plaintiff sustained injuries in the Palmer Veterinary Clinic’s waiting room when a dog attacked her, resulting in bodily injuries. The defendant Palmer raised the vicious propensity rule and argued that it had no prior knowledge of the canine’s vicious propensities. The Appellate Division agreed with...Read More

Take Me Out To The Muddy Ballgame (NY)

This week, we bring you a slip and fall involving a softball game in Smithtown, NY. In Chiaramonte v. Town of Smithtown, 2021 NY Slip Op 01244 (2d Dept. 2021), defendants were granted summary judgment dismissal of all claims for a plaintiff who slipped and fell on muddy field conditions while she was playing a charity softball game organized by defendants. The defendants won dismissal by...Read More

Baseball Player Used Eye As Catcher’s Mitt, Assumed The Risk (NY)

In Grady v Chenango Valley Central School District, Plaintiff, then a high school senior and member of the Chenango Valley High School boys’ varsity baseball team, sustained permanent injuries to his right eye after being struck in the head by a baseball during a combined varsity and junior varsity outdoor baseball practice. Plaintiff commenced this action alleging that his injuries were...Read More

Suffolk County (NY) Operating Protocols – Effective February 22, 2021

As COVID-19 numbers seem to be at least be trending in the right direction, NY courts are preparing to resume in-person proceedings.  (For the time being, remote appearances will remain the norm, but it makes sense to be prepared for in-person litigation.)   Suffolk County has issued new protocols, which you can review here.  Effective February 22, 2021, the new protocols include the...Read More